The Star Wars franchise’s iconic Stormtroopers have been improved by the latest canon property Andor, however an early concept for the Obi-Wan Kenobi collection would have arguably completed so earlier. Of their unique Star Wars trilogy debut and most of their Legends continuity appearances, Stormtroopers are elite Imperial army items whose coaching and tools make them among the many galaxy’s deadliest troopers, regardless of their inferiority to their extra noble predecessors, the Republic’s Clone Troopers. Nonetheless, as a consequence of their seemingly poor marksmanship when preventing protagonists (a typical trope in cinema nicknamed “plot armor”), Stormtroopers have turn into a joke amongst viewers, and this working gag has turn into canonized within the present Star Wars timeline, although latest properties have, fortunately, began to mitigate it – enhancing the troopers within the course of.
Animated exhibits like Star Wars Rebels and live-action properties like The Mandalorian, regardless of their constructive reception, exaggerate the unfavourable notion of Stormtroopers to the purpose the place they not seem to be a reputable menace to any educated combatant, not to mention the exhibits’ respective protagonists. This not solely does a disservice to each exhibits’ storytelling, nevertheless it additionally doesn’t coincide with the elite standing of Imperial Stormtroopers in-universe. Whereas Andor has helped to enhance the picture of Stormtroopers in canon (with out centering the armored troops themselves), Obi-Wan Kenobi almost utilized Clone Troopers as elite troopers as a substitute of the often-mocked Stormtroopers. On this method, the mixture of Andor‘s extra respectful therapy of the Empire’s most feared fighters coupled with the canceled Obi-Wan Kenobi plan proves that Star Wars is lastly recognizing that the Empire’s should be seen as a official menace as soon as once more.
Obi-Wan’s Stormtrooper Marshals Would Have Been A Credible Risk To Obi-Wan
The antagonists of Obi-Wan Kenobi initially consisted of just one Inquisitor, Reva, who’s backed up by a posse of Clone Troopers whose energetic management chip implants brainwash them into Imperial service. These Clone Marshals, fittingly, would have been impeccable marksmen and fully ruthless killers, as a consequence of their brainwashing. This is able to have granted the Obi-Wan collection a useful equal to the Stormtroopers’ unique portrayals, solely the Clone Marshals could be far deadlier than their recruited successors. The Clone Marshals, who would have been led by the minor Star Wars: The Clone Wars character Commander Jet, have been set to be regularly killed off because the collection progressed, however they might nonetheless be a major menace to even the formidable Kenobi.
The Clone Marshals would have been greater than a bodily menace to Kenobi. Whereas the Jedi Normal kills many mind-controlled Clone Troopers in self-defense in Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, he exhibits kindness to a homeless Clone Trooper veteran in Obi-Wan Kenobi episode 2. The present’s unique plan would have had Kenobi work alongside an older Commander Cody, whose management chip has been eliminated, so he could be totally conscious that his Clone Marshal assailants are good males whose free will has been eliminated. This is able to, understandably, seemingly make Kenobi extraordinarily hesitant to make use of deadly power in opposition to them, making Reva’s posse a fair larger menace to Obi-Wan, highlighting the unique intent to enhance the troopers.
Obi-Wan Kenobi May Have Higher Defined What Occurs To Imperial Clones
Whereas brainwashed Clone Troopers have been the Galactic Empire’s first elite preventing power, Star Wars: The Dangerous Batch reveals that the Empire ended clone manufacturing and commenced coaching their recruited Stormtrooper replacements inside a 12 months of Palpatine’s profitable coup. Regardless of this, the Empire nonetheless had younger clones to make the most of in its army, and whereas Imperial clones typically turned the primary wave of Purge Troopers (an anti-Jedi dying squad), Obi-Wan’s Clone Marshal plan would have delved additional into the fates of clones who grew up within the age of the Galactic Empire. The Clone Marshals seemingly serve the identical function as Purge Troopers, however their management underneath Commander Jet implies a key distinction between the 2 kinds of Imperial clones.
Imperial Purge Troopers are stated to be comprised of the final batches of Jango Fett clones, raised and educated within the age of the Empire and brainwashed to stay loyal to the fascist regime. The descriptions of Obi-Wan Kenobi’s deliberate Clone Marshals indicate that the squad is comprised of Clone Wars veterans, which might have offered further perception into the Empire’s use of clones. Rebels and The Dangerous Batch present or indicate older clones getting used as coaching instructors for Stormtroopers however Obi-Wan Kenobi’s Clone Marshals would have proven them getting used as a number of the Empire’s most elite forces, not not like the youthful batches changing into the primary Purge Troopers. This position, though by no means formally seen, represents a major enchancment for Stormtroopers and different imperial troopers.
Kenobi’s Marshal Plan Would Have Made Higher Use Of Commander Cody
Commander Cody, whose long-awaited return to the Star Wars franchise will likely be within the forthcoming Dangerous Batch season 2, almost returned earlier in Obi-Wan Kenobi. Whereas his Dangerous Batch return is welcome, having him turn into an ally of his outdated pal as soon as once more would have been a tasteful little bit of fan service. The Dangerous Batch’s season 2 trailers present Cody sporting Imperial grey trim on his armor and dealing alongside Crosshair, strongly implying that he’s both nonetheless affected by his brainwashing implant or, even worse, is willfully serving the Empire like Crosshair. Whether or not or not Cody in the end leaves the Empire in Dangerous Batch, his deliberate position in Obi-Wan Kenobi would have refreshingly reunited him along with his Clone Wars-era pal and colleague.
The deliberate inclusion of Cody would have additionally led to doubtlessly tragic eventualities during which the previous Clone Commander is confronted with a option to both kill his brainwashed brothers or die. Cody would little question refuse to kill his fellow clones, even when they’re brainwashed, however he would additionally do every thing potential to guard Obi-Wan. This might result in Cody sacrificing himself to guard his Jedi pal, serving as a heartbreaking and tasteful sendoff to one among The Clone Wars’ extra distinguished protagonists and one among Star Wars’ most well-known named clone characters. By initially planning to additional personalize a trooper like Cody, Star Wars has as soon as once more indicated a delicate shift in direction of rehabilitating and redeeming the status of its Stormtroopers.
Andor Is Fixing Star Wars’ Stormtroopers After Obi-Wan Did not
Obi-Wan Kenobi in the end portrayed Stormtroopers as simply defeated cannon fodder, however different canon Star Wars supplies have, fortunately, helped repair their picture. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, significantly in act 3, makes Stormtroopers credible threats to well-trained Insurgent troopers, and Solo: A Star Wars Story depicts Imperial Army Troopers in live-action for the primary time since Return of the Jedi, reminding viewers that of the Empire’s extra frequent and fewer elite preventing power. Andor takes a unique strategy, predominantly exhibiting Imperial Army Troopers and together with a former Stormtrooper as one among its most disciplined and lethal Insurgent characters. Whereas the Star Wars canon continuity has a protracted technique to go so far as repairing the Stormtroopers’ picture, Andor makes up for Obi-Wan Kenobi’s doubtlessly useful unused plans and within the course of highlights a delicate shift in Star Wars‘ strategy.
New episodes of Andor launch on Wednesdays on Disney+.
Need extra Andor articles? Take a look at our important content material under…
