The opinions expressed on this op-ed are these of the creator and don’t essentially replicate the views of Navy.com. If you need to submit your individual commentary, please ship your article to opinions@navy.com for consideration.
This article first appeared in The Dialog.
Confronted with the prospect of sending Russian troops into subterranean fight, Vladimir Putin demurred. “There is no such thing as a must climb into these catacombs and crawl underground,” he instructed his protection minister on April 21, 2022, ordering him to cancel a deliberate storming of a metal plant within the besieged Ukrainian port metropolis of Mariupol.
Whereas Putin’s back-up plan – to type a seal round trapped Ukrainian forces and wait it out – isn’t any much less brutal and there are experiences that Russians should have mounted an offensive on the location, Putin’s hesitancy to ship his forces right into a sprawling community of tunnels below the complicated hints at a fact in warfare: Tunnels could be an efficient instrument in resisting an oppressor.
Certainly for the reason that struggle started in February, experiences have emerged of Ukrainian defenders utilizing underground tunnel networks in efforts to disclaim Russian invaders management of main cities, in addition to to offer sanctuary for civilians.
As an knowledgeable in navy historical past and idea, I do know there may be sound considering behind utilizing tunnels as each a defensive and offensive tactic. Such networks permit small models to maneuver undetected by aerial sensors and emerge in surprising places to launch shock assaults after which primarily disappear. For an invader who doesn’t possess a radical map of the subterranean passages, this could current a nightmare state of affairs, resulting in large personnel losses, plummeting morale and an lack of ability to complete the conquest of their city goal – all components that will have factored in Putin’s resolution to not ship troops underground in Mariupol.
A historical past of navy tunneling from historical roots
Using tunnels and underground chambers in occasions of battle is nothing new.
Using tunnels has been a widespread facet of warfare for millennia. Historical besieging forces used tunneling operations as a method to weaken in any other case well-fortified positions. This usually required engineers to assemble lengthy passages below partitions or different obstacles. Collapsing the tunnel weakened the fortification. If well-timed, an assault performed within the quick aftermath of the breach may result in a profitable storming of the defended place.
One of many earliest examples of this method is depicted on Assyrian carvings which might be 1000’s of years outdated. Whereas some attackers climb ladders to storm the partitions of an Egyptian metropolis, others could be seen digging on the foundations of the partitions.
Roman armies relied closely upon refined engineering strategies equivalent to placing arches into the tunnels they constructed throughout sieges. Roman defenders additionally perfected the artwork of digging counter-tunnels to intercept these utilized by attackers earlier than they offered a risk. Upon penetrating an enemy tunnel, they flooded it with caustic smoke to drive out the enemy or launched a shock assault upon unsuspecting miners.
The success of tunneling below fortifications led European engineers within the Center Ages to design methods to thwart the tactic. They constructed castles on bedrock foundations, making any try to dig beneath them a lot slower, and surrounded partitions with moats in order that tunnels would have to be far deeper.
Though tunneling remained an vital facet of sieges by means of the thirteenth century, it was finally changed by the introduction of gunpowder artillery – which proved a simpler technique to breach fortifications.
Nonetheless, by the mid-Nineteenth century, advances in mining and tunnel development led to a resurgence in subterranean approaches to warfare.
Through the Crimean Battle within the 1850s, British and French attackers tried to tunnel below Russian fortifications on the Battle of Sevastopol. Ten years later, Ulysses S. Grant approved an try to tunnel below Accomplice defenses on the siege of Petersburg, Virginia. In each instances, giant caches of gunpowder have been positioned in chambers created by tunneling below key positions and detonated in coordination with an infantry assault.
Tunneling within the age of airpower
With warfare more and more counting on plane within the twentieth century, navy strategists once more turned to tunnels – undetectable from the skies and protected against falling bombs.
In World Battle I, tunneling was tried as a method to launch shock assaults on the Western Entrance, probably bypassing the opposite aspect’s system of trenches and remaining undetected by aerial observers. Particularly, the Ypres salient in war-ravaged Belgium was the location of a whole bunch of tunnels dug by British and German miners, and the horrifying tales of fight below the earth present one of the vital terrifying vignettes of that terrible struggle.
Throughout World Battle II, Japanese troops in occupied areas within the Pacific constructed intensive tunnel networks to make their forces just about resistant to aerial assault and naval bombardment from Allied forces. Throughout amphibious assaults in locations such because the Philippines and Iwo Jima, American and Allied forces needed to deal with a warren of Japanese tunnel networks. Finally they resorted to utilizing excessive explosives to break down tunnel entrances, trapping 1000’s of Japanese troops inside.
The Viet Cong tunnel networks, significantly within the neighborhood of Saigon, have been a necessary a part of their guerrilla technique and stay a preferred vacationer cease as we speak. A number of the tunnels have been giant sufficient to deal with hospital and barracks services and powerful sufficient to resist something wanting nuclear bombardment.
The tunnels not solely protected Vietnamese fighters from overwhelming American airpower, in addition they facilitated hit-and-run model assaults. Specialised “tunnel rats,” American troopers who ventured into the tunnels armed solely with a knife and pistol, grew to become adept at navigating the tunnel networks. However they may not be educated in enough numbers to negate the worth of the tunnel programs.
Tunnels for terrorism
Within the twenty first century, tunnels have been used to facilitate the actions of terror organizations. Through the American-led invasion of Afghanistan, navy operatives quickly found that al-Qaida had fortified a collection of tunnel networks connecting naturally occurring caves within the Tora Bora area.
Not solely did they disguise the motion of troops and provides, they proved impervious to just about each weapon within the U.S.-led coalition’s arsenal. The complexes included air filtration programs to stop chemical contamination, in addition to large storerooms and complex communications gear permitting al-Qaida management to keep up management over their followers.
And tunneling exercise in and round Gaza continues to offer a instrument for Hamas to get fighters into Israeli territory, whereas on the identical time permitting Palestinians to bypass Israel’s blockade of Gaza’s borders.
Soviet tunnels and Ukraine
Most of the tunnels being utilized as we speak in Ukrainian efforts to defend the nation have been constructed within the Chilly Battle-era, when the USA routinely engaged in overflights of Soviet territory.
To counteract the numerous air and satellite tv for pc benefit held by the USA and NATO, the Soviet navy dug underground passages below main inhabitants facilities.
These subterranean programs supplied a certain quantity of shelter for the civilian inhabitants within the occasion of a nuclear assault and allowed for the motion of navy forces unobserved by the ever-present eyes within the sky.
These identical tunnels serve to attach a lot of the industrial infrastructure in Mariupol as we speak – and have develop into a main asset for the outnumbered Ukrainian forces.
Different Ukrainian cities have related programs, some relationship again centuries. For instance, Odesa, one other key Black Sea port, has a catacomb community stretching over 2,500 kilometers. It started as a part of a limestone mining effort – and up to now, there may be no documented map of the complete extent of the tunnels.
Within the occasion of a Russian assault on Odesa, the native information of the underground passages may show to be a particularly beneficial asset for the defenders. The truth that greater than 1,000 entrances to the catacombs have been recognized ought to certainly give Russian attackers pause earlier than commencing any assault upon town – simply because the tunnels below a steelworks in Mariupol compelled Putin to rethinks plans to storm the ability.
Paul J. Springer is a Professor of Comparative Navy Research, Air College.
This text is republished from The Dialog below a Inventive Commons license. Learn the authentic article.
© Copyright 2022 The Dialog. All rights reserved. This materials will not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
