It is a rush transcript. Copy is probably not in its last type.
AMY GOODMAN: That is Democracy Now!, democracynow.org, The Battle and Peace Report. I’m Amy Goodman, with Nermeen Shaikh.
Lethal night time raids based mostly on defective U.S. intelligence, then coated up by a categorized conflict loophole, that is the main focus of a serious new investigation by reporter Lynzy Billing into CIA-backed Afghan particular forces known as “Zero Units,” which left a path of civilian deaths throughout Afghanistan however have but to be held accountable after the U.S. ended its two-decade-long occupation.
Lynzy Billing initially returned to Afghanistan to search out out extra concerning the deaths of her personal mom and sister almost 30 years earlier, however began to deal with the Zero Units’ night time raids when she first heard eyewitness testimony. Over the following 4 years, she visited the websites of greater than 30 raids in Afghanistan and interviewed a whole lot of individuals, together with survivors and households of victims. She additionally spoke to troopers contained in the Zero Units, who have been the boys tasked with killing their very own compatriots on U.S. orders.
On this clip from a forthcoming ProPublica documentary, two of them, Baseer and Hadi, describe their work in 2019 in Afghanistan’s Logar province close to the Ahead Operations Base Shank. To guard their security, their phrases are spoken by actors.
BASEER: [translated] I’m a member of Afghanistan’s Zero Unit within the east of the nation. As intelligence is available in, the raid is carried out. It’s our commander who offers us data.
HADI: [translated] We simply have the capturing order.
AMY GOODMAN: These are two troopers with the so-called Zero Units in Afghanistan, describing their work to reporter Lynzy Billing in her new exposé for ProPublica, “The Evening Raids.” She’s becoming a member of us now from Istanbul, Turkey. She’s an investigative journalist who’s been reporting on Afghanistan since 2019. Born in Afghanistan, she is a British journalist.
We welcome you, Lynzy, to Democracy Now! Are you able to speak about, lay out the findings of your piece, simply who these Zero Units are, and, the truth is, you going there not precisely to analyze this story, however really your personal household and what occurred to them?
LYNZY BILLING: Yeah. Thanks for having me.
This story actually began in early 2019 once I went again to Afghanistan to look into my previous and what had occurred my household. And it was in Nangarhar province within the east of the nation the place I had met a distant relative, and I used to be investigating the loss of life of my mom in a raid there that had occurred a long time earlier, the place I met a girl known as Mahzala. And he or she was a widow, and she or he was in her fifties, and she or he was by herself, as a result of she was telling me this story of an evening raid that had killed her two solely kids. And after assembly her and seeing this — she was simply at an entire loss as what to do, and she or he actually sort of turned to me as a foreigner to assist her attempt to perceive what had occurred to her sons.
And so, after listening to her story, I simply felt this enormous accountability to look into who was conducting these operations in distant and rural areas of Afghanistan. And that’s once I sort of stumbled throughout the Zero Units, that are squadrons of Afghan particular forces who have been skilled and funded and outfitted by the CIA, and who have been joined on their operations by American particular operations forces members additionally, and, at instances, relying on the operation, CIA advisers. And these have been counterterrorism operations. The Zero Units have been despatched after perceived threats in opposition to the USA, so, first, Taliban and, in later years, ISKP additionally. And so, I began simply listening to increasingly studies of people that — from individuals who had misplaced family members in these operations. And I began to comprehend that they — whereas at some instances they have been efficiently concentrating on militants, that they have been additionally getting it flawed.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Lynzy, what did you find out about why — when the models have been established, what number of models there have been, what number of Afghans and American particular forces have been members of those models? After which clarify why you selected to deal with one in every of them, 02.
LYNZY BILLING: Yeah, so, there’s 4 identified Zero Unit squadrons, and so they’re based mostly regionally throughout the nation. And as you say, I centered on the 02, which was within the east. In Nangarhar, their base is in Jalalabad, however they have been additionally happening operations in neighboring provinces additionally.
And I began to deal with the 02 as a result of the increasingly studies that I saved listening to of civilian casualties and botched operations, it was simply an enormous quantity coming from the 02, and in addition as a result of I used to be in Nangarhar initially, and there was — I simply felt like there was pockets of Nangarhar that have been, at the moment, when this all began in early 2019, that they weren’t being reached by numerous media reporters. They have been actually inaccessible areas. And there was this improve in preventing happening, and it was actually a sizzling spot for these operations. When it began, they have been going out almost each night time. So, it was actually monitoring these operations in actual time.
And that’s why I actually felt like I wanted to talk with troopers who have been contained in the 02. And I wished to know from them why they have been happening these operations on U.S. orders and why they have been concentrating on their very own countrymen. How did they really feel once they went flawed?
And, I imply, these have been enormous operations. These are, you recognize, 80 males on an evening raid, of which 10 to 12 People have been usually becoming a member of, they have been telling me, and large convoys. That they had entry to air energy, as properly, U.S. air energy. And there was simply — they have been so lively in Nangarhar, and everybody knew who the Zero Units have been. They knew what they wore. They knew how — they have been very drastically feared. And but they didn’t know who was behind them or who was compiling the intelligence, who was constructing these concentrating on packages and sending them out to focus on what was turning out to be college students, college college students, academics and farmers. And so, individuals have been actually left with out solutions to what was taking place on these operations.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Lynzy, clarify — I imply, you really managed to talk to those two. We performed a clip earlier of Baseer and Hadi. How did you get them to talk to you, to begin with? And what was particularly placing to you about what they stated in your conversations with them?
LYNZY BILLING: I believe it was — it was most likely about six months after I began on the lookout for troopers contained in the 02 to speak to that I first met Baseer and Hadi. And at first, they have been hesitant to speak to me. They didn’t fairly perceive why I wished to speak to them. And I suppose, over time, there was — they started to belief me and that I did need to hear their perspective on what they have been doing, and in addition their background, which performed a giant position into why they joined these operations — these models initially. They usually actually sort of began opening up over time.
And there was numerous ache and guilt with what they have been doing, and in addition numerous confusion as to their position inside this setup and this construction of the Zero Units, who have been nominally underneath the Afghan intelligence company however have been underneath the umbrella of the CIA program, as properly. They usually actually — I believe, initially, there was one — I bear in mind one particular assembly the place they instructed me about one operation that had killed civilians and that had not resulted to find the Taliban that they have been on the lookout for in that operation, and this type of frustration, from their half, the place they weren’t those who might speak about it, and so they weren’t writing up the after-action studies. It was a senior commanding officer who was doing it. They usually weren’t certain if anybody was even going to search out out concerning the civilians killed in these operations. It was one thing out of their arms. Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: Lynzy, you spoke to a person named Spin Ghar, who says he was shot thrice when he was 12 years outdated by two troopers, two troopers exterior their base in Jalalabad.
LYNZY BILLING: Yeah. And Spin Ghar was — I met Spin Ghar simply this final 12 months, really, by coincidence. And this was — you recognize, the U.S. had now left Afghanistan, and a lot had modified over the course of this investigation, and really shortly, for everybody. However he was actually — he actually caught with me, as a result of once I met him, he had obtained — he had been shot, as you say, thrice exterior his house, which was proper subsequent to the bottom in Jalalabad, the 02 base. And he had been inspired to, you recognize, file papers for compensation, or a compensation declare. And he, for his accidents, had been handled on the base in Jalalabad and in addition Bagram base. And he had filed these papers, and he had obtained a letter again. And it was written in English, and he didn’t communicate English — he didn’t learn English. And it had declined to offer him compensation for his accidents. And he had been ready so lengthy to listen to if he was going to get this compensation for what had occurred on this — on that event.
And he actually caught with me, as a result of that is lengthy after the U.S. has left. And there have been nonetheless individuals in Afghanistan who’re ready to listen to again on guarantees of compensation and issues they’d been inspired to pursue. And this operation focused him when he was 12, though on the shape it was written that he was 14. However he simply felt like this actually, like, telling image, for me, as to what actually was left behind.
AMY GOODMAN: So, I wished to ask you about who’s behind these Zero Units, and significantly why, for instance, that these raids are carried out by the CIA and never the army, what sort of loophole and lack of reporting, investigation or accountability that results in.
LYNZY BILLING: Nicely, there’s a really — it’s a really murky space that these models fall into, exactly, as you say, as a result of they aren’t U.S. army counterterrorism operations. As a result of they fall underneath the CIA, they don’t fall underneath the standard U.S. regulation that might apply to the army or Title 10. And the U.S. particular operations forces troopers becoming a member of these operations additionally don’t fall underneath the identical U.S. legal guidelines, as a result of these are actually covert motion operations. That is Title 50. So there’s this entire authorized loophole into them not receiving the identical oversight and scrutiny that U.S. army operations would.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Lynzy, speak about — I imply, you additionally spoke to a U.S. Army Ranger, who instructed you — who conceded that these night time raids had horrible results, although he stated that they have been preferable to airstrikes, saying to you, “You go on night time raids, make extra enemies, then you definitely gotta go on extra night time raids for the extra enemies you now need to kill.” So, you spoke to him. You additionally look, within the piece, on the historic antecedents, the use by the U.S. of night time raids. What did you perceive about why People, the U.S. army and CIA, use this specific methodology, and have for many years?
LYNZY BILLING: Yeah, I imply, they’ve been utilizing it for many years, utilizing the night time raid technique since 1967, once they have been doing these operations, or capture-kill operations, in opposition to the Viet Cong in South Vietnam, and thru Iraq, through which they have been claimed as having main successes in concentrating on insurgencies and militants. And but that’s not the outcome that we see by means of our reporting, and that’s not the outcome that got here out afterwards. However it was this repeatedly used technique that has failed time and time once more, and that has not had a full accounting of it or what the fallout from these operations is.
AMY GOODMAN: And eventually, what you are feeling, chatting with so many individuals, their perspective towards the USA with the variety of deaths that haven’t been held accountable? And are households making use of? Do they know methods to succeed in out?
LYNZY BILLING: I imply, that is actually — yeah, I imply, that is actually the legacy that America has left behind in Afghanistan. Many individuals I spoke to really feel that these operations had really had the reverse — have been counterproductive and really had turned their households in opposition to the U.S.-backed authorities in Kabul and in opposition to the U.S. And they’ll — if the identical technique is utilized in new conflicts and new wars, with out somebody wanting on the ways and saying, “What’s the failures of this right here? We’re having failures of intelligence,” then they’ll have the identical fallout in different nations, and you will notice a blowback, the identical as you will have in Afghanistan, which is the way in which that folks view the U.S., exactly due to witnessing years of those operations.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, Lynzy, lastly, you conclude your piece by saying, “Ultimately, I bought closure for my very own private story from the unlikeliest supply: Baseer.” Clarify what you came upon, what occurred to your mom and to your sister, and why you say that Baseer offered you with this closure.
LYNZY BILLING: I didn’t get all of the solutions that I used to be on the lookout for with what had occurred to my household. However I do really feel and I believe that that’s actually, partially, one thing that we see in Afghanistan basically, which is that one household’s loss and tragedy is changed by one other as one conflict bleeds into the following and it will get coated up. And so, what occurred to my household was so way back now, after which what occurred with the households I used to be assembly in 2019, up — you recognize, over the previous few years, was a current battle.
However they — I believe that, with Baseer, the rationale I felt some stage of closure with it was as a result of, though he hadn’t focused my household and he hadn’t killed them, there was an understanding from him that sort of surfaced over time and thru our common conferences and conversations over time, this understanding that he had of what the actual, true human price of those operations was and the way everybody was affected, from the households and survivors by means of to the troopers conducting these operations additionally. And so, there was one thing about him reaching that understanding that helped me really feel — it actually loosened somewhat one thing in me to really feel a little bit of closure with seeing that sort of regret of what he had carried out.
AMY GOODMAN: Nicely, Lynzy Billing, we need to thanks a lot for being with us, investigative journalist who’s been reporting on Afghanistan since 2019. We’ll hyperlink to your piece in ProPublica that’s headlined, merely, “The Evening Raids.” Lynzy was chatting with us from Istanbul, Turkey.
We go now to California, the place the loss of life toll has risen to 19 as heavy storms and flooding proceed to devastate a lot of the state. We’ll communicate with a UCLA local weather scientist. Stick with us.
[break]
AMY GOODMAN: “Beck’s Bolero” by the legendary guitarist Jeff Beck, who died Tuesday on the age of 78.
