A assessment of Chinese language counterspace actions

by Matthew Mowthorpe and Markos Trichas
Monday, August 1, 2022

China has an extended historical past of creating area weapons. It has demonstrated a functionality to kinetically intercept satellites in low Earth orbit (LEO) from the bottom. Earlier this 12 months China demonstrated a brand new functionality to cover within the “graveyard” past geostationary orbit (GEO) and re-emerge to grapple a satellite tv for pc in GEO. Moreover, it has the flexibility to make use of ground-based lasers to dazzle satellites in LEO. China has the flexibility to conduct radiofrequency (RF) jamming from cell platforms towards communication satellites in LEO. This text examines China’s ASAT ideas and locations them within the context of their respective navy area doctrines which threatens each US and NATO allies’ satellites.

Regardless of Chinese language statements on area warfare claiming to stick to the peaceable makes use of of outer area, China has designated area as a navy area. The purpose of area warfare and operations is to attain area superiority. Chinese language writings as early as 2012 have declared the necessity for area dominance. Examples embrace: “Profitable efforts at establishing area dominance due to this fact should additionally consider the sustainment of this complete construction of terrestrial and area methods and related information and communications hyperlinks, whereas striving to degrade or destroy an opponent’s.”[1] and “Due to this fact, assaults towards strategic area targets require the course of the highest-level political authorities.”[2]

China co-orbital ASATs

In the summertime of 2010 SHI JIAN-12 (SJ-12) carried out various shut approaches with the SJ-06F satellite tv for pc in LEO (600 to 570 kilometers.) These occurred between June and August 2010. Within the closest strategy, the 2 satellites have been lower than 300 meters aside.[3] SJ-12 was launched into the next inclination, then maneuvered in August 2010 to be basically the identical inclination as SJ-06F

Determine 1: Inclination of SJ-12 (blue) and SJ-06F (purple)[4]

One other proximity operation occurred in LEO in 2013. Three payloads have been positioned in orbit at 670 kilometers from the identical launch on July 19, 2013: SHIYAN-7, CHUANGXIN-3, and SHIJIAN-15. SY-7 was recognized to the Chinese language program as TANSUO-4 and was probably fitted with a robotic arm, which interacted with a separating subsatellite, referred to as TANSUO-3 (CX-3), and was designed to supply optical surveillance in GEO and LEO.[5] SJ-15 was referred to as TANSUO-5 and was designed to maneuver and conduct proximity operations.

On August 9, 2013, TANSUO-5 maneuvered near TS-3 and -4 passing near TS-3 at a distance of some kilometers. TS-5 on August 16 altered its altitude by greater than 100 kilometers to conduct an in depth strategy inside a number of kilometers of SHI JIAN (SJ-7), which was launched in 2005.

On October 18, TS-4 raised its orbit by a number of hundred meters and launched a small object, which was designated as particles. TS-4 and the “particles” orbited in shut proximity for a number of days, ranging between a number of kilometers and several other hundred meters and it was reported that the 2 objects have been joined collectively, with TS-4 clasping the smaller “particles” object. These two objects carried out small maneuvers throughout 2014–15 with the gap by no means exceeding a number of kilometers.[6]

Determine 2: TANSUO-4 with robotic arm and small companion satellite tv for pc[7]

In April 2014, SJ-15 (TS-5) started to conduct maneuvers round TS-3. Between Might 12 and 14, TS-5 maneuvered by decreasing to match orbital planes with SJ-7, and on a trajectory that introduced it above after which behind SJ-7 at a spread of round 150 kilometers with a vertical separation of some kilometers. Throughout Might, TS-5 diminished the gap to SJ-7 to inside a kilometer.[8] In 2015–16, TS-5 (SJ-15) often made adjustments to its orbit nevertheless with no obvious motive, aside from maybe demonstrating applied sciences to carry out proximity operations.

In 2016, the AOLONG-1 (AL-1) small satellite tv for pc, referred to as the Superior Particles Removing Automobile (ADRV), demonstrated utilizing a robotic arm to seize a small piece of particles for elimination from orbit. The AL-1 didn’t conduct any rendezvous operations with any objects and it didn’t seem to vary its orbit throughout its two months on orbit.[9] The satellite tv for pc used a robotic arm to grapple digital targets.[10]

Geostationary rendezvous and proximity operations

On November 3, 2016, China launched the SHIJIAN-17 (SJ-17) into GEO. SJ-17. SJ-17 was reportedly designed take a look at superior applied sciences, nevertheless it was additionally fitted with an onboard optical surveillance sensor,[11] and a reported indicators intelligence mission.[12] Unusually, the YZ-2 higher stage remained in obit with a perigee close to GEO, and can dip down very near and rotate across the energetic GEO belt for many years to return. On November 11, 2016, SJ-17 maneuvered to 162.9 levels east in GEO, comparatively near CHINASAT-5A, a Chinese language communications satellite tv for pc, coming as shut as few kilometers by November 30. On the finish of 2016, SJ-17 drifted away and commenced a speedy drift east of two levels per day, and 4 levels west per day on February 9, 2017, till on March 20 it lowered its orbit and moved to rendezvous and proximity operations (RPO) with CHINASAT-20, a navy communications satellite tv for pc.[13]

On July 29, 2018, SJ-17 carried out a RPO with CHINASAT-1C, a communications satellite tv for pc that had an unexplained anomaly and had begun drifting westward at 0.5 levels per day. On January 23, 2018, SJ-12 raised its inclination from 0.43 to roughly 4 levels, and maneuvered to a drift of 4 levels per day, earlier than reversing again to zero between July 20 and 22, 2018. The massive change in inclination suggests the SJ-17 has vital delta-vee functionality as airplane change maneuvers are amongst essentially the most power intensive. SJ-17 got here inside 1.5 kilometers of CHINASAT-1C and extremely probably carried out inspection for ten days to evaluate the supply of the anomaly and monitor the restoration try of CHINSAT-1C.[14] In 2020, SJ-17 made RPO with CHINASAT-6B in January, and with SJ-20 in October.

Determine 3: Longitudinal historical past of SJ-12 since launch in 2017 together with main RPO with Chinese language communications satellites[15]

On December 23, 2018, China launched one other mission to GEO, the Tongxin Jishu Shiyan (TJS)-3. Two objects have been catalogued from the launch, TJS-3 and a second object, 43917. What was uncommon about 43917 is that in did a collection of maneuvers to put it into GEO at 59.07 levels east close to TJS-3. It seems that 43917 is subsatellite and sustaining an in depth distance, about 100–200 kilometers, from TJS-3. In April 2019, TJS-3 left object 43917 and moved to a different location, suggesting preliminary checkout befell close to object 43917.[16]

It is a vital program of testing in LEO and GEO undertaken by the Chinese language authorities that goes past that could possibly be deemed essential for satellite tv for pc inspection, area particles elimination, and area situational consciousness. It’s probably these applications could possibly be a part of wider counterspace capabilities. The testing of a robotic arm could possibly be used for damaging a satellite tv for pc to forestall it working. As a Protection Intelligence Company (DIA) report lately concluded “China is creating subtle on-orbit capabilities, reminiscent of satellite tv for pc inspection and restore, not less than a few of which might additionally operate as a weapon.”[17]

The anomaly of RPO for in-orbit servicing and a counterspace weapons lies in the truth that the onboard monitoring and steerage could possibly be used to collide with one other satellite tv for pc to break or destroy it. A caveat is that, so far, the Chinese language RPO satellites would want greater relative velocities and longer closing distances.[18] Whereas particles elimination and in-orbit servicing could possibly be characterised as benign actions, such property at the moment are directed by the PLA Strategic Help Forces.[19] This means that actions which have been as soon as below civilian purview could possibly be switched when required as this system is directed and led by the PLA.

An extra potential offensive use of RPO can be to put in a radiofrequency jammer onboard the chaser satellite tv for pc, rising its capacity to intervene with the satellite tv for pc’s communications. Chinese language educational papers acknowledged that lowering the gap with a small satellite tv for pc platform would lower the ability necessities exponentially, figuring out inclined US property such because the Superior Extraordinarily Excessive Frequency satellites.[20] This, coupled with the Chinese language doctrine that China can defeat the USA “community centric warfare” with “energy-centric warfare,” signifies that China has a big curiosity in creating high-frequency and directed power weapons in area.

China’s SJ-21 uncommon actions

On October 24, 2021, China launched Shijian-21 (SJ-21) with China’s state-run Xinhua information company reporting its mission as “primarily used to check and confirm area particles mitigation applied sciences.”[21] On November 1, a brand new object was catalogued (2021-094C) alongside SJ-21, which is doubtlessly its AKM (Apogee Kick Motor) as catalogued the US Area Pressure 18th Area Management Squadron. There was hypothesis that this object alongside SJ-21 could possibly be a sub-satellite launched after arriving in GEO.[22] This hypothesis relies on the truth that each objects seem to stay 5 kilometers aside and intentionally synchronized after finishing a re-rendezvous on November 15.[23] If the AKM was ejected a steadily rising separation can be anticipated. The character of the proximity operations of the AKM and SJ-21 shouldn’t be recognized, it could possibly be a part of China’s counterspace testing.

On January 22, 2022, SJ-21 was noticed to execute a big maneuver to carry itself intently subsequent to a lifeless Beidou navigation satellite tv for pc. SJ-21 pulled the lifeless satellite tv for pc out of its geosynchronous orbit and positioned it a number of hundred miles right into a graveyard orbit. SJ-21 gave the impression to be performing as an area tug. On January 26, SJ-21 launched the Beidou and maneuvered again close to GEO. The capabilities the SJ-21 demonstrated could possibly be utilized in a counterspace function to maneuver different satellites in geosynchronous orbit. The technological demonstration of the SJ-21, whileperhaps having reliable functions to take away defunct satellites with depleted gas reserves to the graveyard orbit, might additionally serve a counterspace function.

Chinese language direct-ascent ASAT

The Chinese language direct ascent program’s first recognized assessments have been in 2005 and 2006, utilizing the SC-19, additionally known as Dong Neng-1 (DN-1), and is probably going a variant primarily based on the DF-21 cell collection of ballistic missiles. On January 11, 2007, the DN-1 launched from Xichang and efficiently destroyed a defunct Chinese language Feng Yun-1C climate satellite tv for pc at an altitude of 865 kilometers.[23] This ASAT take a look at created a considerable amount of particles[25] and generated a big quantity of worldwide condemnation.

On Might 13, 2013, a probable take a look at of a DA-ASAT that would attain greater orbits befell from Xichang.[26] This take a look at was reported by the Chinese language Academy of Sciences as a high-altitude scientific analysis mission. The Discover to Airmen (NOTAM) launched by China that offered advance warning of the flight path lined a floor observe which lined up with a GEO launch trajectory. Additionally, technical evaluation carried out by the Union of Involved Scientists, primarily based on it re-entering above the Indian Ocean, indicated that the take a look at had an apogee of 30,000 kilometers with a flight time of 6.7 hours.[27] That is per US navy official statements on the time of “almost to GEO”. This new ASAT take a look at variant was labelled DN-2, with an estimated operational timeframe of 2020–25.[28]

A current Nationwide Air and Area Intelligence Middle report acknowledged that “China has navy items which have begun coaching with anti-satellite missiles.”[29] Extra lately, the Director of Nationwide Intelligence reported in 2019 that: “The Folks’s Liberation Army (PLA) has an operational ground-based ASAT missile meant to focus on low-Earth-orbit satellites, and China most likely intends to pursue extra ASAT weapons able to destroying satellites as much as geosynchronous Earth orbit.”[30] It’s probably that DN-1 is operational as that is meant to focus on satellites in LEO, nevertheless, DN-2 is probably going in growth maybe by 2025.

Chinese language digital warfare

Digital warfare (EW) within the context of area is outlined because the intentional interference with an adversary’s RF transmissions to or from a satellite tv for pc.

China is assessed to be proficient in international navigation satellite tv for pc system (GNSS) jamming capabilities and developed each fastened and cell methods. The recognized methods are downlink jammers, which might have an effect on GNSS receivers in an area space.[31] There is no such thing as a open supply literature that signifies that China can goal the uplink jamming of GNSS satellites.

A US vessel travelling in Shanghai in 2019, the Manukai, reported that its GPS methods had been jammed on the berth, as each of the ships GPS items had misplaced their indicators, and its AIS transponder had failed. A final-ditch emergency system, like AIS, additionally relied on GPS couldn’t get a repair[32]. Certainly there was proof that the GPS methods had been spoofed as its true place and pace had been changed by false coordinates broadcast from the bottom.

In line with open supply information in April 2018, China put in tools able to jamming communications and radar methods on two of its fortified outposts on the Spratly Islands within the South China Sea.[33]

The PLA throughout workout routines routinely incorporates jamming and anti-jamming strategies towards a number of communication, radar methods, and GPS satellite tv for pc methods in workout routines. A Protection Intelligence Company report assessed that China is creating jammers to focus on SATCOM over a spread of frequency bands together with navy protected extraordinarily excessive frequency communications.[34]

Determine 4: DigitalGlobe picture commissioned by the US navy displaying the Jamming Gear with its antenna prolonged.[35]

Given the significance of EW in Chinese language navy doctrine it’s probably that China is creating a ground-based artificial aperture radar (SAR) jamming functionality. The previous GSD Third Division (now SSF) oversaw a division leader-grade unit, headquartered in Shanghai, answerable for the intercept of Satcom and SAR transmissions.36]

EW gives flexibility its results are non permanent, reversible, could possibly be utilized towards a selected satellite tv for pc, and it doesn’t generate any area particles. It additionally doesn’t increase the bar when it comes to escalation throughout a battle as a kinetic assault maybe would. Army GNSS indicators are extra resilient to jamming. Jamming as an interference methodology may degrade navy GPS methods however it’s unlikely to disclaim them utterly. In a battle between China and the US, China would most likely use their jamming and anti-satellite methods to disrupt US traces of communication, command and management, situational consciousness and efforts at navy coordination.[37]

Chinese language directed power weapons

China is actively pursuing the event of directed power weapon (DEW) for counterspace use. There’s a vital quantity of proof of analysis and growth, and testing however restricted particulars on operational standing of any deployed capabilities.[38] The usage of lasers as a weapon is characterised in three results:

• Dazzling a satellite tv for pc’s imaging sensor
• Injury to a satellite tv for pc’s imaging sensor
• Injury to the satellite tv for pc bus or subsystems

The impact of dazzling is non permanent, and is taken into account a countermeasure reasonably than a weapon. Relative low energy ranges are required to dazzle. A ten-watt laser could possibly be ample to create a stunning impact and obscure an space from being imaged.[39] The brink between dazzling and injury is nearly unattainable to foretell, as it might rely upon data of a goal satellite tv for pc’s inside design and protecting mechanisms. To be used as a weapon to trigger vital injury to the sensor, an influence stage within the kilowatt vary can be required. A really-high-power laser can be required to trigger injury to the satellite tv for pc bus. The injury can be because of the heating results of the power inflicting the important elements such because the thermal regulation system, the batteries, or perspective management system.[20]

It was reported in 2006 that China used a ground-based laser to dazzle or “blind” a US optical surveillance satellite tv for pc on not less than one event.[41] China has not less than 5 websites that assist China’s DEW work:

• Two websites on the Centre for Atmospheric Optics, Anhui Institute for Optics and High quality Mechanics in Hefei
• Chinese language Academy of Engineering Physics in Mianyang, Sichuan Province
• Korla Missile Take a look at Facility in Xinjiang Province

Equally, industrial imagery of Xijiang Province beneath exhibits an analogous format to the opposite amenities, indicating DEW analysis is being carried out. The power has 4 predominant buildings with sliding roofs, with three of the sheds linked with two vacuum spheres. The form and measurement point out that presumably chemical lasers are getting used.[42] It’s postulated that the tools below the smaller sliding shed is used for monitoring, whereas the opposite three are used individually or along with one another. Each the Hefei and Mianyang amenities have equally massive rectangular buildings with retractable roofs and counsel amenities the place DEW aimed toward satellites might have been developed.[43]

Determine 5: Chinese language ground-based laser ASAT at Xinjiang Province[44]

Chinese language ground-based laser testing was presumably confirmed by a Chinese language article from scientists working on the Changchun Institute of Optics, High quality Mechanics and Physics:

In 2005, now we have efficiently carried out a satellite tv for pc blinding experiment utilizing a 50-100 KW capability mounted laser gun in Xinjiang province. The goal was a low orbit satellite tv for pc with a tilt distance of 600 km. The diameter of the telescope firing the laser beam is 0.6 m vast. The accuracy of ATP (acquisition, monitoring and pointing) is lower than 5 [microradians.][45]

The positioning of the ground-based laser was probably situated at Korla, Xinjiang province. It’s probably that China has developed extra highly effective ground-based lasers since this take a look at.[46] A current DIA evaluation assessed that China presumably already has a “restricted functionality to make use of laser methods towards satellite tv for pc sensors.”[47] It postulated that China could subject the next energy system by mid-to-late 2020s able to threatening the construction of non-optical satellites.[48]

There may be restricted reporting from the Changchun Institute of Optics, High quality Mechanics and Physics scientists article inspecting the cancelled US ABL in 2011 that China has an airborne laser program for ASAT use. Within the Chinese language Communist Celebration celebrations in 2009 a museum displayed a picture of a four-engine plane utilizing a laser to assault a satellite tv for pc.[49] This might point out that China is continuous to conduct analysis into the feasibility of utilizing an ABL in an ASAT functionality.

The identical Changchun authors argue for the feasibility of a Chinese language space-based laser weapon. The authors conclude “In future wars, the event of ASAT [anti-satellite] weapons is essential. Amongst these weapons, laser assault system enjoys vital benefits of quick response pace, sturdy counter-interference efficiency and a excessive goal destruction charge, particularly for a space-based ASAT system. So the space-based laser weapon system will likely be one of many main ASAT growth tasks.”[50] Whereas the flexibility of China to develop such a system within the acknowledged timeframe of 2023 is in query, the need to develop such a system exists with the technical area neighborhood.

Chinese language counterspace doctrine

The institution of the Strategic Help Pressure (SSF) in December 2015 was tasked with integrating area intently into operations. When it comes to counterspace, the SSF’s Area System Division seems to be answerable for not less than the co-orbital counterspace mission. The SSF’s Community System unit signifies that it’s answerable for jamming satcom and GPS, in addition to pc community operations towards area amenities and satellites.[51] Direct ascent capabilities could have been retained by the PLA Rocket Pressure.

Chinese language navy writings state the purpose of area warfare and operations to attain area superiority, outlined as “guaranteeing one’s capacity to totally use area whereas on the similar time limiting, weakening, and destroying an adversary’s area forces.”[52]

Endnotes

1. D. Cheng, China’s Position in Area, Strategic Research Quarterly, Spring 2012, 68.
2. D. Cheng, China’s Position in Area, Strategic Research Quarterly, Spring 2012, 70.
3. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 35
4. Brian Weeden, “Dancing within the Darkish; The Orbital Rendezvous of SJ-12 and SJ06F,” The Area Evaluation, August 30, 2010.
5. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 36
6. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 38
7. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 37
8. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 38
9. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 39
10. “Re-Entry: Aolong-1 Area Particles Removing Demonstrator”, 28 August 2016.
11. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 40
12. D. Chen, Listening to on “China’s Superior Weapons”, Panel on China’s Directed Vitality and Electromagnetic Weapons Programmes, 23 Feb 2017.
13. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 41
14. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 41
15. Knowledge compiled by the COMSPOC Company quoted in B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 42
16. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 43
17. DIA, Challenges to Safety in Area, January 2019, 21
18. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 44
19. Namrata Goswami, Earlier than the U.S.-China Financial and Safety Evaluation Fee Listening to on “China in Area: A Strategic Competitors?” April 25, 2019.
20. D. Chen, Listening to on “China’s Superior Weapons”, Panel on China’s Directed Vitality and Electromagnetic Weapons Programmes, 23 Feb 2017.
21. NASA Grasp Catalog.
22. Kristin Burke, China’s SJ-21 Framed as Demonstrating Rising On-Orbit Servicing, Meeting, and Manufacturing (OSAM) Capabilities, China Aerospace Research Institute, December 2021, 6.
23. Jonathan’s Area Report, 28 Nov 2021.
24. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 45
25. The quantity of trackable particles is assessed by The Safe World Basis as 3,280.
26. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 47
27. B. Weeden, “Via a glass, darkly: Chinese language, American and Russia anti-satellite testing in area”, The Area Evaluation, 17 March 2014.
28. 2015 US Annual Report back to Congress, 294.
29. NASIC Report, “Competing in Area” December 2018, 12.
30. D. Coats, Director of Nationwide Intelligence, Assertion for the Document, Worldwide Menace Evaluation of the US Intelligence Group, 29 January 2019, 17.
31. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 53
32. Mark Harris, “Ghost Ships, Crop Circles, and Comfortable Gold: A GPS Thriller in Shanghai,” MIT Expertise Evaluation, 15 November 2019.
33. M R Gordon and J Web page, “China Put in Army Jamming Gear on Spratly Islands, US says”, Wall Road Journal, 9 April 2018.
34. DIA, Challenges to Safety in Area, January 2019, 20
35. M R Gordon and J Web page, “China Put in Army Jamming Gear on Spratly Islands, US says”, Wall Road Journal, 9 April 2018.
36. M Stokes, US Listening to on “China in Area: A Strategic Competitors” , 25 April 2019, 4
37. L Wortzel, The Chinese language PLA and Area Warfare, 9
38. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 54
39. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 56
40. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 56
41. NRO Confirms Chinese language Laser Take a look at Illuminated US Spacecraft, 3 Oct 2006, Area News.
42. Vinayak Bhat, “These Futuristic Chinese language Area Denial Weapons Can Disable or Destroy Opposing Satellites,” The Print, March 23, 2019.
43. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 57
44. Vinayak Bhat, “These Futuristic Chinese language Area Denial Weapons Can Disable or Destroy Opposing Satellites,” The Print, March 23, 2019.
45. R. D. Fisher China’s Progress with Directed Vitality Weapons testimony to Congress 23 Feb 2017, 6
46. R. D. Fisher China’s Progress with Directed Vitality Weapons testimony to Congress 23 Feb 2017, 5
47. DIA, Challenges to Safety in Area, January 2019, 20
48. DIA, Challenges to Safety in Area, January 2019, 20
49. R. D. Fisher China’s Progress with Directed Vitality Weapons testimony to Congress 23 Feb 2017, 6
50. R. D. Fisher China’s Progress with Directed Vitality Weapons testimony to Congress 23 Feb 2017, 7
51. Kevin L. Pollpeter, Michael S. Chase, and Eric Heginbotham, The Creation of the Strategic Help Pressure and Its Implications for Chinese language Army Area Operations, (Santa Monica: RAND, 2017.
52. B. Weeden and V. Samson, International Counterspace Capabilities, April 2021, 63

Dr. Matthew Mowthorpe at the moment works within the UK Army Future Programmes at Airbus Defence and Area. Previous to this, he labored on the Ministry of Defence, the place he managed the Area Crew inspecting threats to and from Area. Dr Mowthorpe has printed in quite a few journals on the weaponization of area and notably printed the guide The Militarization and Weaponization of Area printed by Rowman and Little within the US.

Dr. Markos Trichas is the Head of UK Nationwide Eyes Solely Area applications at Airbus Defence and Area UK. He has been with Airbus for 9 years. Prior of becoming a member of Airbus he labored at Harvard CFA/NASA CXC, STFC RAL, and Imperial Faculty London. He holds a PhD in Astrophysics from Imperial Faculty London.

Be aware: we’re utilizing a brand new commenting system, which can require you to create a brand new account.