For 56 years, Mary Dowling has pushed to Joint Base Lewis-McChord from her Tenino dwelling to go to the grave of her husband, Bob Dowling, a adorned helicopter pilot killed within the Vietnam Conflict.
On each go to, Mary would flip her gaze to the plot subsequent to his, safe within the information and the promise from the Army that the empty grave web site would in the future be hers.
Till Veteran’s Day final November. That is when she noticed freshly turned earth and realized another person had been buried in her plot.
“I could not imagine it,” Mary mentioned. “And I did not know what to do. I simply stood there for some time.”
Mary, who by no means remarried after her husband’s demise, had acquired annual assurances from the Army that her plot was safe. A board outdoors the doorway listed her title on the grave web site. A map, nonetheless on the Army’s web site, clearly reveals two side-by-side plots listed as “Dowling.”
When the couple’s 4 youngsters grew to become adults, they periodically checked with the cemetery to ensure their mom’s closing want can be carried out.
In a number of conferences with the household during the last three months, the Army has admitted a mistake was made and supplied a number of options. None contain giving Mary her plot again and he or she has stood agency that’s the solely answer she’s going to settle for.
Now, the Army and the 83-year-old widow are at an deadlock.
Assembly Bob
Mary and her future husband each grew up in Centralia, however did not meet till 1957, simply after she had graduated from Centralia Excessive Faculty. The 18-year-old school pupil quickly grew to become smitten with Dowling, then 19.
“I simply thought he was very good-looking,” she recalled. The U.S. Marine Corps reservist with the tight crew reduce was a pointy dresser in pullover sweaters, khakis and loafers. It did not harm that he drove a Corvette.
They married in November 1958.
Dowling had been flying planes since he was 16, Mary mentioned. However it was the comparatively new world of helicopters that quickly attracted his eye.
“He was loopy about flying,” Mary mentioned. “That was his favourite factor.”
In 1963, Dowling left the Marines and joined the Army to change into a helicopter pilot. On the opposite aspect of the world, a long-simmering battle in a rustic few Individuals had heard of was about to warmth up.
Vietnam
When Lyndon B. Johnson took workplace in late 1963 following the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, he ramped up America’s help of South Vietnam.
“It did not take too lengthy after that,” Mary mentioned. “We have been involved that he would possibly get despatched over there.”
Dowling deployed to Vietnam in spring 1965 as a chief warrant officer with the Army’s 197th Armed Helicopter Firm. Mary remembers the day he left Fort Lewis. Dowling was sporting his fatigues and holding the fingers of his three daughters, 2, 3 and 5 years outdated on the time, and his son, Bobby, 4.
“The evening earlier than he left, he talked to Bobby and instructed him that he was the person of the home now although he was solely 4,” Mary mentioned.
Classes from dad
That son, Bobby Dowling, can recall that evening prefer it was yesterday, he mentioned in a telephone interview from his North Carolina dwelling in January.
“He got here into my bed room. He was in his uniform,” Bobby recalled. “I simply keep in mind standing up and he gave me a hug. And he mentioned, ‘You are man of the home now, Bobby. You maintain your mother and your sisters’.”
“And I all the time have,” Bobby mentioned, his voice choked with emotion.
Bobby recalled strolling the grounds of Fort Lewis together with his father. They wore matching Army uniforms. The boy’s haircut mimicked his father’s crew reduce.
“I used to be actually his shadow,” Bobby mentioned. “In fact, I needed to look as much as him each figuratively and actually.”
The Dowlings have a historical past of service within the U.S. army courting to the Civil Conflict. Dowling’s stepfather was a B-17 tail gunner in World World II. Bobby’s father-in-law was an admiral within the U.S. Navy.
Someday earlier than his father deployed in 1965, Bobby went to a Centralia drugstore with him. There, unbeknownst to his father, Bobby swiped a pack of chewing gun. Later at dwelling, Dowling requested him the place he bought the gum. Bobby confessed.
“And he took me again to the shop,” Bobby mentioned. “I keep in mind trying on the proprietor and I needed to apologize. And I simply mentioned, ‘I am sorry, I will not do it once more.’ And that, to me, was the turning level.”
Bobby credit that proper versus unsuitable second as a template for the remainder of his life, together with a profession as a particular agent with the Naval Prison Investigative Service (NCIS) and later with the Division of Homeland Safety, assigned to the FBI.
“That actually was form of a North Star for me in my profession when it comes to the place I ended up,” he mentioned.
Shot down
On Jan. 1, 1966, Bob Dowling’s helicopter was shot down, giving him a sprained left hand and a extreme blow to the pinnacle. Nonetheless, he salvaged a grenade launcher and a rifle and returned fireplace till his ammunition was expended, in response to Army data. When a rescue helicopter landed, Dowling supplied cowl fireplace and refused to depart his place till his crew was safely aboard the plane.
He was quickly flying once more, however he had time to put in writing Mary a letter describing the incident. It might be the final she would obtain from him.
On Jan. 12, 1966, Dowling was flying a mission alongside the coast of the South China Sea in an space often called Tuy Hoa. He was to choose up and relocate a unit of Korean Marines.
Through the flight, Dowling’s UH-1B Huey was hit by enemy fireplace. It fell into the ocean. Dowling and his wounded co-pilot, Russ Kistler, made out it of the craft.
Dowling’s wingman, Lt. Col. Byron Byerly, steered his helicopter towards Dowling, however he waved him off. He wished Kistler rescued first.
After selecting up Kistler, Byerly returned to Dowling.
“Simply as I approached Bob, an enormous hammerhead shark lifted Bob up out of the water then took him down” Byerly recounted within the e book “Returning Hearth”. “I will always remember the look on his face when the shark hit. It was over straight away.”
Byerly hovered for a couple of minutes, hoping for a miracle, he mentioned. Dowling died at age 27 — Lewis County’s first casualty within the Vietnam Conflict. On the time, the Army mentioned Dowling died from enemy fireplace.
“It ought to be made report that Bob Dowling died a hero,” Byerly mentioned. “His unselfishness in telling me to maintain Russ first was the bravest act I ever noticed and it value him his life.”
A telegram arrives
Again in Centralia, a taxicab driver introduced Mary a telegram. Her husband was lacking in motion.
“I used to be simply in shock,” Mary recalled.
She tried to cover her concern from her youngsters.
“After which my mom came visiting after she’d gotten a telegram and he or she was in dangerous form and crying and the children have been asking what was unsuitable with Nana?,” Mary mentioned.
A couple of days later, uniformed officers confirmed up at her dwelling with the information no army household desires to listen to.
It was as much as Mary to make the funeral preparations. Dowling had been adamant that he would return from Vietnam alive.
“He refused to say that something would occur to him,” Mary mentioned. “He mentioned, ‘No, I am gonna be again once more. And nothing’s going to occur’.”
Mary selected the Fort Lewis cemetery as a result of the Army publish was the primary the place they’d been stationed.
“I simply felt a connection to Fort Lewis,” she mentioned. “And the cemetery was actually fairly.”
She will be able to recall Dowling’s burial and subsequent memorial like photos in a photograph album: the flag-draped casket unloaded from a prepare. The flyover of Army helicopters within the lacking man formation. The commanders and their speeches.
Dowling was posthumously awarded the Purple Coronary heart, the Distinguished Flying Cross and the Bronze Star for Valor, given to Army personnel who present distinctive heroism in fight.
Reassured
Shortly after Dowling was buried within the cemetery, Mary acquired the primary of what grew to become annual letters from the cemetery.
“They requested me if I used to be nonetheless single,” Mary mentioned. “And if I nonetheless want to retain my reservation, and so I all the time checked the packing containers and despatched the shape proper again.”
In later years, after these letters stopped coming, she requested Bobby and her daughters to verify with the cemetery to ensure her plot was nonetheless secure.
Since her husband’s burial, Mary has visited the cemetery each Memorial Day and Veterans Day. She matches in a couple of further visits throughout the yr.
Generally she brings flowers. Different instances she comes armed with towels and cleanser to ensure Dowling’s marble marker shines brightly.
“And each time I went, the massive title board, simply outdoors the inside gate to the gravestones, all the time had my title on it,” she mentioned. “I might all the time go over and have a look at it.”
Grave mistake
On Nov. 12, Mary visited the cemetery, a bouquet in her fingers.
When she approached her plot, she seen freshly dug earth. A brief grave marker with a stranger’s title was positioned on it. Then she seen the plot map outdoors the cemetery entrance was gone.
Shortly after that day and within the ensuing weeks, Mary and different relations met with and referred to as JBLM employees and officers to grasp the error and the way it might be remedied. They have been instructed transferring the serviceman buried in Mary’s plot was not an possibility.
The Army gave Mary three decisions: 1) have her casket positioned on prime of her husband’s, supplied there was room; 2) Have her cremains positioned on prime of her husband’s casket or 3) Be buried in one other close by plot.
Mary rejected all three. She wished the plot promised to her.
“They broke a promise and it is morally unsuitable,” Mary mentioned. “And it reveals disrespect for a soldier who died in fight for his nation, for his widow for his or her youngsters and for all Gold Star households.”
Bobby hopes that the inherent promise of help the army makes to its households, and particularly its Gold Star households — a designation given to households who’ve had a member of the family killed in a time of battle — will probably be saved. He described the Army’s mortuary personnel as compassionate and he hopes that compassion extends to his mom.
The Army’s response
In an in depth assertion emailed to The News Tribune on Feb. 10, David Fullmer, JBLM Garrison Chief of Workers, mentioned the Army regrets any errors made concerning Mary’s deliberate interment on the Fort Lewis Publish Cemetery. The Army, he mentioned, had no report of annual verification letters mailed to Mary or any data exhibiting a reserved plot for her though Fullmer didn’t doubt these letters have been despatched.
“And not using a reservation we can’t hold plots obligated indefinitely and deny different veterans and eligible relations a spot of relaxation,” Fullmer mentioned.
Fullmer acknowledged each on-line and bodily maps confirmed the Dowling title on two plots.
“Nobody at present working at JBLM is aware of who produced or maintained the map,” Fullmer mentioned. “The map ought to have solely mirrored individuals really buried on the cemetery. Nonetheless, the map lends credence there was a plot reservation for Mrs. Dowling at one time.”
Someday between 1984, when the map was made, and August 2022 when data have been uploaded in to the cemetery’s official burial administration system, Mary’s reservation was misplaced, in response to the Army.
Moreover, Fullmer mentioned the plot reserved for Mary couldn’t have held a casket with out disturbing an adjoining row of buried urns. The stays buried in October in Mary’s plot are cremains in an urn. That urn can’t be moved as a result of interments are thought of closing and everlasting, in response to Army laws.
A January go to
A sturdy overhead signal marks the doorway to Camp Lewis Publish Cemetery. Fir bushes and moss-covered boulders line the street to a small car parking zone. The roughly 1,000-plot graveyard is a small oasis within the bustling base.
In late January, Mary visited the cemetery together with her daughter Bonnie Pollard by her aspect. A reporter and photographer with The News Tribune and Army public info officer Joe Piek accompanied them.
It is a quick stroll from the cemetery entrance to the Dowling plots. On at the present time, solely helicopters passing overhead broke the silence. They reminded Mary of her husband’s funeral, she mentioned.
“56 years is such a very long time that I simply anticipated that I might be buried right here subsequent to my husband and it is very important me,” Mary mentioned, taking a look at her now occupied plot. “It was my plot for all that point … I simply do not perceive why…”
A everlasting marker for the person buried in her plot was not too long ago erected. Each Mary and Bobby say they’ve respect for the person and his household.
“I simply really feel very sorry that they’d their loss,” Bobby mentioned.
The Dowlings don’t have any animosity towards the Army, they mentioned. They merely need the promise made to Mary greater than half a century in the past to be saved.
“I am having dangerous goals about it,” Mary mentioned. “I simply give it some thought always. It actually bothers me.”
Pollard has seen the toll it is taking over her mom.
“I’ve heard how devastated she is and the way she will be able to’t sleep at evening,” Pollard mentioned. “I feel she’s being nicer than she must be.”
“I am on the stage the place I would want it any day,” Mary mentioned earlier than taking one final have a look at the grave web site.
A gathering
On Feb. 3, JBLM officers met once more with Mary and different relations. In accordance the Dowling household, officers admitted a mistake had been made however have been adamant the stays buried in Mary’s plot couldn’t be moved.
The Army had probed the graves and located there was sufficient room to put Mary’s casket adjoining to her husband’s as a result of his casket was barely offset from his gravestone. As an alternative of her personal gravestone, her title might be engraved on the again of his, she was instructed.
In a letter to the Army dated Feb. 4, Mary Dowling rejected that possibility.
“For my part, the one approach to right this error is to make the grave web site that has been promised to me for nearly six a long time accessible to me once more,” she mentioned.
___
(c)2023 The News Tribune (Tacoma, Wash.)
Go to The News Tribune (Tacoma, Wash.) at www.TheNewsTribune.com
Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
Present Full Article
© Copyright 2023 The News Tribune, Tacoma, Wash.. All rights reserved. This materials is probably not printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
