The allegedly avowed white supremacist and anti-Semite had a historical past of dressing like Adolf Hitler and speaking approvingly of Nazis, coworkers advised investigators.
WASHINGTON — The legal professional for a former U.S. Army reservist needs to query potential jurors subsequent month about their views on Adolf Hitler and Nazism – an try to get forward of damning proof about his consumer’s alleged anti-Semitic and white supremacist views.
Federal prosecutors and legal professional Jonathan Crisp filed their joint proposed voir dire movement Friday laying out the questions potential jurors could possibly be requested subsequent month when Crisp’s consumer, Timothy Hale-Cusanelli, goes to trial on seven counts in reference to the Capitol riot. These counts embody felony prices of civil dysfunction and obstruction of an official continuing that would carry hefty jail sentences if he is convicted.
Hale-Cusanelli was working as a safety officer at Naval Weapons Station Earle in Colts Neck, New Jersey, on Jan. 6 when he’s accused of becoming a member of the mob of Trump supporters who stormed the U.S. Capitol Constructing. Hale-Cusanelli was arrested lower than two weeks after the riot and has been held in pretrial detention ever since – in no small half due to studies from dozens of coworkers that he was an avowed white supremacist and Nazi sympathizer and spoke approvingly a couple of coming civil conflict.
At the least 34 coworkers advised federal investigators that Hale-Cusanelli made no secret of his excessive anti-Semitic and racist beliefs, in keeping with court docket paperwork. He was recognized to put on a Hitler-style mustache – a photograph of which jurors are prone to see at trial – and to usually put up extremist rhetoric on-line. One Navy seaman who spoke with investigators recalled Hale-Cusanelli telling him that if he was a Nazi “he would kill all of the Jews and eat them for breakfast.” One other Navy petty officer stated he remembered Hale-Cusanelli saying, “Jews, girls and Blacks had been on the underside of the totem pole.” Nonetheless one other petty officer stated he recalled Hale-Cusanelli telling him, “Hitler ought to have completed the job.”
Hale-Cusanelli is scheduled to start trial on Could 23. Forward of that, his legal professional, Crisp, submitted a collection of questions he’d wish to ask potential jurors within the case. Whereas a lot of them have been normal in different Capitol riot trials – questions on whether or not jurors dwell or work close to the Capitol, the place they get their information, in the event that they had been personally affected by Jan. 6 – others are distinctive to Hale-Cusanelli’s specific alleged fascination with anti-Semitism and the Nazi Get together. The questions embody:
- Do you suppose somebody who impersonates Adolf Hitler, satirical or in any other case, is an individual who would wish to overthrow the federal government?
- Do you suppose somebody who’s a white supremacist needs to overthrow the federal government?
- Do you suppose a Nazi sympathizer needs to overthrow the federal government?
- Do you suppose an individual can categorical mistrust with the federal government with out eager to overthrow it?
Whereas the DOJ is opposing these questions, it is going to be as much as U.S. District Decide Trevor McFadden to determine whether or not Crisp can ask them. Based on former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani, now president of West Coast Trial Legal professionals, judges are inclined to lean towards the protection relating to questions in regards to the jury choice course of.
“I feel what the choose might say is, chances are you’ll hear proof that Hale-Cusanelli was a white supremacist. Can you continue to determine whether or not he supposed to overthrow the federal government by pressure?” Rahmani stated. “That’s actually the usual. Are you able to set aside these two? And that’s what the protection is asking for.”
From the DOJ’s perspective, Rahmani stated, the case has nothing to do with race. It’s a couple of need to overthrow the federal government – and Hale-Cusanelli’s extremist rhetoric reveals the pumped was already primed when he got here to D.C. on Jan. 6. The protection’s aim, Rahmani stated, will probably be to attempt to separate these two issues as a lot as potential.
“Principally what they’re arguing is, look, it’s potential to be a white supremacist Nazi sympathizer and never wish to overthrow the federal government,” Rahmani stated. “They need the jurors to say, hear, he could be a racist however not be responsible of revolt.”
Prosecutors may have greater than YouTube movies and alleged racist statements to make their case. Based on court docket paperwork, Hale-Cusanelli admitted to a confidential supply shortly after the fitting that he’d entered the Capitol and inspired different members of the mob to advance, “giving instructions through each voice and hand indicators.” Hale-Cusanelli additionally alleged stated in the event that they’d had extra males they might have taken over all the constructing and stated he’d taken a flag one other rioter had thrown at an officer “like a javelin” – a probable reference to the allegations in opposition to former U.S. Special Forces soldier Jeffrey McKellop, who’s set to start trial on Could 9 – with the intent to destroy it. The dialog was recorded by the confidential supply, and is prone to be a key piece of proof within the authorities’s case in opposition to Hale-Cusanelli.
Hale-Cusanelli additionally has pending motions asking for essentially the most severe prices in opposition to him to be dismissed or for a change of venue. For the previous, Hale-Cusanelli has claimed former President Donald Trump ordered him an others to enter the Capitol constructing and has additionally cited a call by McFadden that one other defendant, Matthew Martin, confirmed it was “believable” he believed police had allowed him into the constructing. Thus far, no Capitol riot defendants have had their trials moved out of D.C., and just one choose has agreed to drop essentially the most severe obstruction cost in opposition to a single defendant.
We’re monitoring all the arrests, prices and investigations into the January 6 assault on the Capitol. Join our Capitol Breach Publication right here so that you just by no means miss an replace.
