A U.S. Army Ranger previously stationed at Joint Base Lewis-McChord was sentenced Friday to twenty years in jail for beating a safety guard to demise in downtown Tacoma after he went out ingesting with different Rangers.
Spc. Patrick Philip Byrne pleaded responsible in March to first-degree homicide within the July 18, 2021 demise of 41-year-old Denise Smith. The lady had labored simply 5 shifts on the 12-story Frank Russel Constructing, 909 A St., earlier than Byrne attacked her.
Surveillance video confirmed the soldier assault Smith for 8 to 10 minutes, in keeping with court docket information, dragging her by the hair and repeatedly punching her earlier than utilizing the guard’s keys to stab her within the face, apparently making an attempt to gouge her eyes out, information state. He then flipped Smith onto her abdomen and choked her till she went limp, then continued to choke her for an additional minute or two.
After the assault, Byrne tried to smash a window in a convention room and threw round furnishings within the foyer. He then exited, and in keeping with charging paperwork fell or jumped from a ledge 14-feet above road stage. He ultimately was dropped at a hospital, the place he informed detectives he had no reminiscence of what occurred.
Six of Smith’s kin spoke throughout the listening to, and extra sat within the courtroom gallery with an indication that included a photograph of the girl in her safety officer uniform. Smith’s sister, Tina Renee Mack, wore all inexperienced. She stated it was her sister’s favourite shade, and he or she needed Byrne to think about Smith’s title at any time when he noticed it.
“I simply needed Patrick to know that he destroyed our lives, and abruptly took a life and made it very exhausting to proceed on with life,” Mack stated.
Smith grew up in Seattle, the place she graduated from Rainier Seashore Excessive Faculty in 1998, however her household hails from Indiana. Her eldest brother, Dennis Mack, informed the court docket he was introduced up within the Midwest, and he protects his sisters. He additionally believes in a watch for a watch, and he stated if this occurred the place he got here from, it will be him sitting in court docket.
“I am making an attempt to not be on Court docket TV, choking his eyeballs out his head. However that is what I wish to do,” Dennis Mack stated. “I am by no means going to forgive him for what he did.”
Byrne stated in court docket Friday he nonetheless can’t keep in mind any particulars from that evening.
His legal professional from the Division of Assigned Counsel, David Katayama, wrote in court docket filings that earlier than the homicide, Byrne turned concerned in a bodily altercation at The Workplace Bar & Grill the place he was punched within the head and knocked to the concrete. Minutes after gaining consciousness, Byrne was forcibly making an attempt to enter the constructing the place Smith was working.
Earlier than handing down the sentence, Pierce County Superior Court docket Decide Stanley Rumbaugh stated there was legitimacy to the protection legal professional’s statements, which led him to consider Byrne had some ingredient of lack of capability when he dedicated the crime.
However Rumbaugh additionally stated he believed that Byrne wanted to know that getting intoxicated to the purpose of changing into belligerent and uncontrollable in a public place is a selection. The decide stated the defendant additionally knew he had prior head accidents from his time within the army and from automobile wrecks, however he selected to exacerbate these issues by ingesting alcohol in extra.
“It is fascinating to listen to you speak concerning the future and your future plans as a result of Denise Smith has no future,” Rumbaugh stated. “She was brutally murdered in an act that’s as callous and as merciless as this court docket has ever had the misfortune of coping with. It, it is actually simply unspeakably merciless.”
A mind scan confirmed Byrne had a mind bleed within the space of the organ that controls morality and judgment, in keeping with Katayama, and he wrote in court docket filings that two docs who reviewed Byrne’s medical information independently concluded that the mind harm was attributable to a blow to the top such because the one described by witnesses to the bar combat.
The punishment Rumbaugh imposed was in keeping with a really useful sentence agreed on by prosecutors and the protection, the low finish of the usual sentencing vary for defendants prosecuted in comparable instances, which is 20 to 26 years in jail. Byrne had no prior felony convictions.
Deputy Prosecuting Legal professional Thomas Howe wrote in court docket filings that had the case gone to trial, a jury would conclude based mostly on surveillance video that Byrne induced Smith’s demise, however there was an actual concern of reality in regard to his psychological state. And the truth that a motive will not be nicely understood is an element that would make a unanimous resolution tough for a jury.
“He is pleading a murder-one, so it was my perception that when somebody, no matter their motivation is, comes ahead, pleads to principally the highest half, which is the place I feel we would find yourself after trial, that I’ll conform to a low-end suggestion,” Howe stated in court docket.
Byrne wrote in court docket filings that he was accepting a plea settlement to not trigger extra ache to his household and the household of the sufferer.
The defendant remained on lively obligation Thursday pending the completion of his civilian felony trial, a spokesperson for his unit, the seventy fifth Ranger Regiment, informed The News Tribune. However the Army has began the executive separation course of, and it was anticipated to be accomplished quickly.
Byrne was raised in New York and North Carolina in an Irish Catholic household, and he joined the army at age 23 following the occasions of Sept. 11, 2001, in keeping with the protection’s sentencing memorandum. He has a historical past of great head accidents, together with two auto accidents he survived as a younger man, in addition to accidents within the army. He reportedly suffered a “blast concussion” and a serious fall after his parachute did not deploy in an airplane leap.
Previous to Smith’s homicide, Byrne had not too long ago returned to JBLM after a two-month deployment to Afghanistan.
When it was his time to handle the court docket, Byrne stated he might by no means describe how actually sorry he was, and he prayed that Smith’s household would settle for his deepest apology. Talking by means of tears, he stated this by no means would have occurred if not for the top harm he sustained from being assaulted.
“I want I had by no means gone to that bar, that I had by no means gone out in any respect that evening,” Byrne stated. “I want I had by no means ever even been out right here, then none of this is able to have occurred. And Denise Smith, an excellent and fantastic lady, to make certain, she would nonetheless be alive and a part of the world for a lot for much longer.”
Exterior the courtroom, Tina Mack informed The News Tribune that it was exhausting to say if Byrne had obtained a good sentence. A life is gone, she stated, and he nonetheless has one. However on the identical time, she stated, justice has been served. Mack stated the person’s apology appeared real.
“I really feel he’s sorry for what he is carried out. I am a forgiving particular person. It may take some time, however my coronary heart does exit to him. It does. I do not assume he is a foul particular person, I simply assume it was a foul scenario.”
___
(c)2024 The News Tribune (Tacoma, Wash.)
Go to The News Tribune (Tacoma, Wash.) at www.TheNewsTribune.com
Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
Story Continues
© Copyright 2024 The News Tribune, Tacoma, Wash.. All rights reserved. This materials might not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
