The making of Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller

It was late spring 2004. Stuart Scheller, a freshly minted accountant and up to date College of Cincinnati graduate, was watching ­photographs on tv of Marines in Iraq transferring ­street-to-street in the course of the 1st Battle of Fallujah.

It introduced him again to 2001, when, as a freshman in school, he had watched the Sept. 11 assaults on TV, resisting the urge to ­enlist in order that on the request of his mother and father he may end his school diploma.

He was the son of a profession businessman, and someday wished to affix the FBI. However, deep inside him, Scheller determined that his place was main Marines on “the sting of the Empire.”

“I simply thought I may go into the FBI ­anytime,” Scheller informed Marine Corps Occasions in a cellphone interview. “However, this warfare might not ­at all times be occurring, and I wished the chance to serve my nation. So, I referred to as the Marine recruiter and began my path.”

By January 2005 Scheller was in officer ­candidate college. And just a bit greater than a 12 months after his first name to a Marine recruiter, Scheller received his want.

In January 2006, he was a freshly minted Marine Corps infantry platoon commander, coming into the fight forces on the eve of the most costly stretch of American involvement within the World Battle on Terrorism.

Rising up

Scheller’s alternative to affix the Marines was a little bit of a shock, in keeping with his mother and father. But it surely didn’t come as a complete shock both.

Rising up within the Midwest, principally outdoors of Cincinnati, Ohio, Scheller excelled each athletically and academically, traits the Marine Corps covets in the course of the officer recruitment course of.

“Stuart was an all-state Ohio soccer participant in highschool,” Stuart Scheller Sr. stated. “Stuart was at all times a straight-A pupil, very clever.”

Whereas Scheller’s mother and father had by no means been within the army, his household boasts an extended historical past of army service.

In line with his mom, Cathy, her household has had an ancestor struggle in each U.S. warfare besides Vietnam courting again to the Revolution.

Extra instantly, Scheller’s paternal grandfather — whom Scheller Sr. stated Scheller was very near and who imbued a way of responsibility and repair on him as a baby — landed on Omaha Seashore in Normandy, France, throughout World Battle II.

“He knew that my dad was very pleased with him only for being a superb pupil and for his athleticism,” Scheller Sr. informed Marine Corps Occasions in an October 2021 interview. “He most likely wished to make my dad proud as nicely by becoming a member of.”

Though Scheller had expressed curiosity within the Marine Corps to his mother and father within the 12 months 2000 out of highschool and once more after 9/11, it nonetheless was a shock to them when he finally determined to affix in 2004. In spite of everything, the warfare in Iraq was heating up, unbeknownst to the household that the bloodiest years have been nonetheless to come back.

“He stated, ‘I do know what I don’t need to do, Dad, I don’t actually need to be an accountant,’” Stuart Scheller Sr. stated. “And I’m considering, ‘Holy cow, he simply spent 4 years in school, with an accounting diploma.’ However, he wished to affix the Marine Corps, and we fully supported him.”

Regardless of the dangers to life and limb and the transfer right into a profession subject Scheller Sr. had little familiarity with, he knew his son would do nicely. Stuart ­Scheller Jr. had confirmed himself a pacesetter on the athletic subject and within the classroom. And his father knew he had imbued his personal robust management philosophy onto his son.

Scheller Sr. has a observe file of success, ­working on the enterprise government stage for almost 40 years. That features spending greater than 20 years working a well being care consulting ­enterprise, the place he offers government teaching and ­management counseling.

Stuart Scheller Sr.’s core philosophy, handed onto his son, relies on “managing all the way down to your individuals and lifting them up” whereas serving to them “develop” and “enhance” and “leaders lead by ­instance.”

In brief, leaders are accountable to their individuals, he says.

Time within the Corps

Scheller Jr. checked into his first unit, 1st ­Battalion, eighth Marine Regiment, in early 2006 and obtained an prompt eye-opening into the ­realities of warfare.

As he stood in entrance of his platoon for the primary time, he seen that a lot of them have been carrying sweatsuits relatively than the prescribed uniform of the day. Scheller requested his platoon sergeant why.

“He stated, ‘Sir, all of them have physician’s notes as a result of all of them have shrapnel nonetheless of their physique from the push by way of Fallujah,” Scheller recounted. “That was the second for me to say, ‘That is actual.’ Identical to the load of the world hits you with the duty.”

Nonetheless, when it got here to fight Scheller must wait.

His first deployment with 1st Battalion, eighth Marines, in 2006 was as a part of a Marine expeditionary unit. Though they educated in Kuwait and evacuated noncombatants from Beirut that 12 months, as an entire the battalion didn’t deploy into Iraq.

The 12 months 2007 although, was a distinct story.

In September 2007, the Marines of 1/8 obtained orders to Ramadi, Iraq — within the coronary heart of the Sunni “triangle of loss of life” and carrying the fame of one of the violent cities in Iraq.

Now an organization government officer in Alpha Firm, 1st Battalion, eighth Marines, Scheller instantly made an impression as a pacesetter, Matt Underhill, a former platoon commander in the identical firm, informed Marine Corps Occasions.

“Stu is simply a kind of strong leaders that you just simply felt good in regards to the route of Marine Corps once you met Stu and labored with Stu,” ­Underhill stated. “That is what I hoped for amongst my friends and amongst whomever’s ­main me.”

Underhill stated that Scheller developed a private relationship with all his subordinate leaders. This, in flip, made Underhill’s job, the corporate ­commander’s job and the lifetime of the Marines of their cost “straightforward.”

Moreover, Underhill talked about a thread that might grow to be related almost 20 years later: accountability up and down the chain of ­command, with Scheller on the heart.

“He would maintain us accountable,” Underhill stated. “He would maintain himself accountable. I imply, I truthfully really feel like if the necessity had arisen, he would have held the corporate commander accountable.”

Underhill added that Scheller was neither a “maverick” nor a “cowboy” when it got here to his skilled fashion. Moderately, his opinion, Scheller Jr. was very a lot “by the e book,” however with a private fashion that constructed confidence and respect from these round him.

“He was at all times placing the Marines, and I’d say the junior Marines forward of him. It was that selfless servanthood management.” Underhill stated. “Commanders want they’d extra guys like Stu. I gained’t say subordinates, however his junior Marines wished they’d extra management like Stu.”

Following the unit’s return from Iraq, Scheller continued to see his star develop as a pacesetter within the Marine Corps.

From 2008–2010 he served as an organization commander on the Faculty of Infantry–East, positioned at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, the place he oversaw the fight growth of enlisted Marines.

Wanting, in his phrases, to expertise ­Afghanistan, Scheller accepted a person augmentation billet with the Joint Improvised ­Explosive Machine Defeat Group.

From June 2010–July 2011, Scheller deployed to Afghanistan with the Army as a part of that group, helping in growing counter-IED strategies. His efforts with the Army abroad led to the award of a Bronze Star Medal, together with an Army Commendation Medal.

Upon his return from Afghanistan in 2011, Scheller was chosen to ­attend expeditionary warfare college in Quantico, Virginia, the place he earned a grasp’s diploma in army science and operational research.

The-now Capt. Stuart Scheller ­assumed command of a Marine Corps infantry firm with third Battalion, 2nd Marine ­Regiment, aboard Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, and headed out to sea on one other MEU deployment.

Michael Welter, then a corporal beneath Firm Commander Capt. Stuart Scheller, stated the Marine instantly stood out.

“He was a pacesetter,” Welter informed ­Marine Corps Occasions. “He was honest, and he was emotionally and mentally invested within the success of the ­human beings under him. Not simply as a ­Marine, however as a human being.”

Welter described how Scheller’s management fashion resonated nicely among the many junior enlisted at sea. In brief, Welter stated, Scheller often would come to their berthing space with no particular motive aside from to see how his Marines have been doing.

“The berthing space, simply sort of the residing areas suck,” Welter stated. “However he’d nonetheless are available in and be like, ‘Hey, the way you guys doing?’ … ­Actually would sit down simply chit-chat. ­Ensuring all people’s doing positive.”

Scheller at all times was asking if his Marines wanted something for coaching, logistics or just enhancing their high quality of life, Welter stated.

“For an 0-3 to do this is that claims quite a bit,” Welter stated. “Not solely in regards to the tradition that he was making an attempt to construct in his firm, but in addition about him as a human being.”

Scheller’s fame as a reliable officer and chief of Marines resulted in him being chosen to coach future Marine officers at officer candidate college and The Fundamental Faculty. As a rule, the Marine Corps invests its finest expertise into its coaching applications.

Retired 1st Sgt. Dale Barbitta first met Scheller whereas working at OCS in 2012. Nonetheless, it wasn’t till 2019 that he labored immediately with Scheller when the 2 have been ­assigned to Marine Particular Operations ­Command.

Barbitta, who in 2019 was about to retire from the Marine Corps, spoke bluntly about the kind of chief Scheller was.

“If I may have assured that he would have been my battalion commander, or I might have labored in the identical command as Stu, I might have stayed in,” Barbitta informed Marine Corps Occasions.

Barbitta stated that leaders within the Marine Corps comparable to Scheller are few and much between.

In line with him, Scheller ­allowed these beneath his command the pliability to make their very own calls, as long as the mission, no matter it was, ended up achieved.

One of many issues Barbitta most ­appreciated about Scheller’s ­management was his emphasis on ­communication each up and down the chain of command, which Barbitta stated allowed all Marines within the chain of command to really feel valued and concerned.

Scheller confirmed humility when he arrived at MARSOC, Barbitta stated.

Scheller, who got here from a ­typical infantry background, understood how ranges and different coaching workouts have been carried out otherwise in MARSOC.

Scheller maintained a “first to reach and final to go away” mindset and devoted his efforts to enabling his Marines. Additional, he continually requested his senior enlisted how typical techniques translated or didn’t into the world of MARSOC.

“He’s only a nice f*cking chief,” Barbitta stated.

He’s ‘not a hothead’

The ultimate cease in Scheller’s Marine Corps profession was again at Infantry Coaching Battalion in North Carolina.

From June 2021 till his firing following his public cry for accountability went viral in late August, he served as battalion commander.

Whereas Scheller says that the assault in Kabul, which claimed the lives of 13 service members, together with 11 Marines, sparked him to talk out on Aug. 26, 2021, the rationale behind it was extra difficult.

Scheller says that as he started to ­obtain textual content messages relating to the fallen, together with some Marines he knew, he felt in his intestine that the “failure” of the withdrawal in Afghanistan was by no means going to be addressed by senior management and that the conduct of your complete warfare would by no means be referred to as into query.

“I sat there in my chair and thought, ‘I don’t suppose senior leaders get it,’” Scheller stated. “I don’t suppose they perceive the failures. I can’t suppose in army historical past, no less than during the last 30 or 40 years has been such a monumental failure, and never one particular person has acknowledged it.”

Moreover, Scheller felt that the one manner that there can be even an try at accountability for the withdrawal can be for him to talk out publicly only one time.

“I believed, ‘I’ll make one video,’” Scheller stated. “I’ll clarify a number of the issues that I believe they need to have executed and demand ­accountability ­as a result of that’s what I believe we deserve.”

There was a lot public hypothesis relating to Scheller’s determination to go public. He sacrificed his Marine Corps profession, a retirement he spent 17 years working towards, and in his phrases, the transfer value him his marriage. Nonetheless, the Marines that spoke with Marine Corps Occasions didn’t see Scheller’s public name as such.

Barbita, who labored with Scheller till mid-2020, a little bit greater than a 12 months earlier than Scheller went viral together with his calls for for accountability,ndescribed Scheller as very deliberate and calculated. Barbita described Scheller as somebody who, when making selections, would seek the advice of a number of opinions earlier than making a call.

“He was very, he’s very ­aware of his ideas and actions,” ­Barbita stated. “He’s very, I imply very, ­methodical together with his selections.”

Underhill noticed Scheller as an officer destined to be a profession Marine, probably rising to basic or increased. Additional, he described Scheller as a “stone-cold skilled” who could be very “calm, cool and picked up.”

“Stu will not be a hothead,” ­Underhill stated. “So, if Stu is upset by the present scenario and the dearth of accountability — America must pay attention.”

Learn Half 2: ”The unmaking of Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller.”

RELATED